- Home
- ...
- Finance and Accounting Business Process Outsourcing Service Providers
- Collective
- QuickBooks Live Bookkeeping
- Collective-vs-QuickBooks Live Bookkeeping
Compare Collective and QuickBooks Live Bookkeeping 
- Users report that QuickBooks Live Bookkeeping has a solid quality of work rating at 8.8, but reviewers mention that Collective excels with a higher rating of 9.7, indicating a more thorough and reliable bookkeeping service.
- Reviewers mention that the responsiveness of Collective is notably better, scoring 9.7 compared to QuickBooks Live Bookkeeping's 8.8, suggesting that users feel more supported and attended to with Collective.
- G2 users highlight the expertise of the team in Collective, which scored 9.7, while QuickBooks Live Bookkeeping received a score of 9.0, indicating that users find Collective's team to be more knowledgeable and skilled.
- Users on G2 report that Collective's professionalism is rated a perfect 10.0, while QuickBooks Live Bookkeeping scored 9.0, suggesting that users feel more confident in the professionalism of Collective's service.
- Reviewers mention that Collective's execution ability is rated at 9.8, significantly higher than QuickBooks Live Bookkeeping's 8.9, indicating that users find Collective to be more effective in delivering results.
- Users say that Collective's planning features, such as resource allocation and needs assessment, are rated higher than those of QuickBooks Live Bookkeeping, which suggests that users find Collective to be more adept at strategic planning and management.
Biggest differentiator is the white-glove customer service. Does not feel like a normal subscription platform and their teams are very attentive and work to resolve questions very quickly.
Despite feedback given to Collective over nearly 3 years, I've experienced repeated mistakes in my bookkeeping, and in taxes they filed for me which they then had to amend. They charged me for another year after I gave them nearly 3 months notice and have...
My QuickBooks live bookkeeper is patient and willing to review the numbers with me regularly to make sure that all of the postings are correct. Using the QB live also was a much better value that using my CPA to do my bookkeeping.
Everything. What we disliked was - everything about it. After signing up you must wait a substantial period to meet with the bookkeeper (basically a month for a monthly service). That meeting will go over the details, talk about expectations, and generally...
Biggest differentiator is the white-glove customer service. Does not feel like a normal subscription platform and their teams are very attentive and work to resolve questions very quickly.
My QuickBooks live bookkeeper is patient and willing to review the numbers with me regularly to make sure that all of the postings are correct. Using the QB live also was a much better value that using my CPA to do my bookkeeping.
Despite feedback given to Collective over nearly 3 years, I've experienced repeated mistakes in my bookkeeping, and in taxes they filed for me which they then had to amend. They charged me for another year after I gave them nearly 3 months notice and have...
Everything. What we disliked was - everything about it. After signing up you must wait a substantial period to meet with the bookkeeper (basically a month for a monthly service). That meeting will go over the details, talk about expectations, and generally...
