- Home
- ...
- Finance and Accounting Business Process Outsourcing Service Providers
- Collective
- Pilot
- Collective-vs-Pilot
Compare Collective and Pilot 
- Users report that Pilot excels in its "Statement of Work" feature, achieving a perfect score of 10.0, which reviewers mention helps in clearly defining project scopes and expectations, while Collective also performs well but slightly trails with a score of 9.8.
- Reviewers mention that Collective shines in "Professionalism," receiving a perfect score of 10.0, indicating that users feel they are treated with utmost respect and care, whereas Pilot scores 9.7 in this area, suggesting a slightly less formal approach.
- G2 users highlight Pilot's "Scope Management" capabilities, scoring a perfect 10.0, which reviewers say allows for excellent control over project parameters, while Collective also scores well at 9.8, but some users feel it could improve in this area.
- Users on G2 report that Collective's "Execution Ability" is superior, with a score of 9.8, which reviewers mention translates to a more efficient project delivery process compared to Pilot's score of 9.5.
- Reviewers mention that Pilot's "Resource Allocation" feature scores 9.7, which users say helps in effectively distributing tasks among team members, while Collective's score of 9.5 indicates room for improvement in this aspect.
- Users say that both products have strong "Technical Expertise," but Pilot's score of 9.9 is slightly higher than Collective's 9.7, suggesting that Pilot may have a slight edge in providing technical support and knowledge during projects.
- Real-time visibility into your finances
- Monthly P&L and balance sheet based on your bank and credit card activity
- Year-end package for your tax preparer
Biggest differentiator is the white-glove customer service. Does not feel like a normal subscription platform and their teams are very attentive and work to resolve questions very quickly.
Despite feedback given to Collective over nearly 3 years, I've experienced repeated mistakes in my bookkeeping, and in taxes they filed for me which they then had to amend. They charged me for another year after I gave them nearly 3 months notice and have...
Ease of platform, friendly and helpful team, and smooth onboarding process of clients.
Worst bookkeeping service we've ever experienced. They failed to properly recognize revenue. We sell hardware and software. The hardware is supposed to be recognized as revenue in the month it shipped. For an entire 18-months, they failed to follow this...
Biggest differentiator is the white-glove customer service. Does not feel like a normal subscription platform and their teams are very attentive and work to resolve questions very quickly.
Ease of platform, friendly and helpful team, and smooth onboarding process of clients.
Despite feedback given to Collective over nearly 3 years, I've experienced repeated mistakes in my bookkeeping, and in taxes they filed for me which they then had to amend. They charged me for another year after I gave them nearly 3 months notice and have...
Worst bookkeeping service we've ever experienced. They failed to properly recognize revenue. We sell hardware and software. The hardware is supposed to be recognized as revenue in the month it shipped. For an entire 18-months, they failed to follow this...
