What do you dislike about Smartlead?
I ran my agency on Smartlead and bought my clients' domains and mailboxes through their SmartSenders add-on. Here's what happened, with dates:
- Jul 16: Mailboxes I bought came with no passwords. Support blamed vendor maintenance and said to wait 24-48 hours (ticket #383332).
- Sep 13-18: Starting Aug 17, Smartlead's own emails to my account were being suppressed. Because of that, 20 domain purchases on Sep 13 never got past checkout. A simple admin email change locked me out with an expired link and a 5-day cooldown. I was blocked for a week across five support contacts. During the change I was told my account looked deleted, and two support calls got double-booked, which Smartlead admitted.
- Sep 18: I reported that more than 100 domains I'd bought through them came without CNAME or DKIM set up. Their account manager said moving my clients' mailboxes and domains to another account "depends on how each account was provisioned." He offered a walkthrough "Monday." I have no record that it ever happened.
- Oct 22-23: A mailbox I'd ordered didn't show up (ticket #419535). Support "accidentally" closed the chat, and the mailbox was added only after I chased it.
- Nov 3-5: I asked to move one client to their own Smartlead account (ticket #423775). Support said no, contradicting the September answer. They marked the ticket "solved" the same day while it was still open. Their workaround only works if you have one client.
- Nov 5: I escalated to the account manager about charges for orders that were never fully delivered, after raising it three times. I got no reply.
- Nov 7-9: Support confirmed that SmartSenders mailboxes can never move and apologized for "the mixed messages." The domains can leave only if you cancel and delete everything first. My client has to rebuy everything for $1,707.50 and warm it all up from zero. Meanwhile the charges stay on my card. As of today the credit for the undelivered orders is still open.
If you're an agency, don't buy domains or mailboxes through Smartlead. You can't hand them to a client, and support won't fix what you've already paid for. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.