LeadMagic Pros and Cons: Top 5 Advantages and Disadvantages

Quick AI Summary Based on G2 Reviews

Generated from real user reviews

Users commend LeadMagic for efficient campaign management, enhancing data quality and simplifying integration with other tools. (1 mentions)
Users find that LeadMagic's data accuracy significantly improves their email campaign effectiveness and maintains a healthy mailbox. (1 mentions)
Users highlight the ease of use of LeadMagic, appreciating its straightforward implementation and smooth integration. (1 mentions)
Users find LeadMagic's easy implementation enhances their email campaigns, streamlining data enrichment effortlessly. (1 mentions)
Users find the easy setup of LeadMagic beneficial for seamless integration with their Outbound tech stack. (1 mentions)
Users report significant data inaccuracy with LeadMagic, leading to unreliable information that damages business operations. (2 mentions)
Users express frustration over limited credits and unclear cancellation processes, leading to unexpected billing issues. (2 mentions)
Users express frustration with poor customer support, emphasizing delays and ineffective responses regarding refunds and account issues. (2 mentions)
Users find the error handling in cancellation processes unclear, leading to unexpected billing and a lack of transparency. (1 mentions)
Users are frustrated by the filtering difficulty in LeadMagic, leading to inaccurate data and wasted resources. (1 mentions)

5 Pros or Advantages of LeadMagic

1. Campaign Management
Users commend LeadMagic for efficient campaign management, enhancing data quality and simplifying integration with other tools.
See 1 mentions

See Related User Reviews

Kevin M.
KM

Kevin M.

Small-Business (50 or fewer emp.)

5.0/5

"Great Tool - All In One Email Validation Tool Meets all Validation and Enrichment needs A**********"

What do you like about LeadMagic?

We use lead magic primarily as a data enrichment tool for bulk lists of emails that we pull from other data platforms. Its great and using it really e

2. Data Accuracy
Users find that LeadMagic's data accuracy significantly improves their email campaign effectiveness and maintains a healthy mailbox.
See 1 mentions

See Related User Reviews

Kevin M.
KM

Kevin M.

Small-Business (50 or fewer emp.)

5.0/5

"Great Tool - All In One Email Validation Tool Meets all Validation and Enrichment needs A**********"

What do you like about LeadMagic?

We use lead magic primarily as a data enrichment tool for bulk lists of emails that we pull from other data platforms. Its great and using it really e

3. Ease of Use
Users highlight the ease of use of LeadMagic, appreciating its straightforward implementation and smooth integration.
See 1 mentions

See Related User Reviews

Kevin M.
KM

Kevin M.

Small-Business (50 or fewer emp.)

5.0/5

"Great Tool - All In One Email Validation Tool Meets all Validation and Enrichment needs A**********"

What do you like about LeadMagic?

We use lead magic primarily as a data enrichment tool for bulk lists of emails that we pull from other data platforms. Its great and using it really e

4. Easy Implementation
Users find LeadMagic's easy implementation enhances their email campaigns, streamlining data enrichment effortlessly.
See 1 mentions

See Related User Reviews

Kevin M.
KM

Kevin M.

Small-Business (50 or fewer emp.)

5.0/5

"Great Tool - All In One Email Validation Tool Meets all Validation and Enrichment needs A**********"

What do you like about LeadMagic?

We use lead magic primarily as a data enrichment tool for bulk lists of emails that we pull from other data platforms. Its great and using it really e

5. Easy Setup
Users find the easy setup of LeadMagic beneficial for seamless integration with their Outbound tech stack.
See 1 mentions

See Related User Reviews

Kevin M.
KM

Kevin M.

Small-Business (50 or fewer emp.)

5.0/5

"Great Tool - All In One Email Validation Tool Meets all Validation and Enrichment needs A**********"

What do you like about LeadMagic?

We use lead magic primarily as a data enrichment tool for bulk lists of emails that we pull from other data platforms. Its great and using it really e

5 Cons or Disadvantages of LeadMagic

1. Data Inaccuracy
Users report significant data inaccuracy with LeadMagic, leading to unreliable information that damages business operations.
See 2 mentions

See Related User Reviews

Sanim M.
SM

Sanim M.

0.5/5

"Shady Setup, Disappointing Experience"

What do you dislike about LeadMagic?

I am extremely dissatisfied with LeadMagic due to several issues. Firstly, the setup process, while easy, was misleading. They claimed to offer 100 fr

Kevin M.
KM

Kevin M.

Small-Business (50 or fewer emp.)

5.0/5

"Great Tool - All In One Email Validation Tool Meets all Validation and Enrichment needs A**********"

What do you dislike about LeadMagic?

Like all data enrichment tools it doesn't get everything right 100% of the time but it is pretty much there in terms of what it offers for the cost.

2. Limited Credits
Users express frustration over limited credits and unclear cancellation processes, leading to unexpected billing issues.
See 2 mentions

See Related User Reviews

SK

Stanislav K.

Small-Business (50 or fewer emp.)

0.5/5

"Unclear cancellation flow, billed for months with no usage"

What do you dislike about LeadMagic?

We canceled in July and received a refund, but importantly, I had to confirm with support that the subscription was actually canceled because the proc

Sanim M.
SM

Sanim M.

0.5/5

"Shady Setup, Disappointing Experience"

What do you dislike about LeadMagic?

I am extremely dissatisfied with LeadMagic due to several issues. Firstly, the setup process, while easy, was misleading. They claimed to offer 100 fr

3. Poor Customer Support
Users express frustration with poor customer support, emphasizing delays and ineffective responses regarding refunds and account issues.
See 2 mentions

See Related User Reviews

SK

Stanislav K.

Small-Business (50 or fewer emp.)

0.5/5

"Unclear cancellation flow, billed for months with no usage"

What do you dislike about LeadMagic?

We canceled in July and received a refund, but importantly, I had to confirm with support that the subscription was actually canceled because the proc

Sanim M.
SM

Sanim M.

0.5/5

"Shady Setup, Disappointing Experience"

What do you dislike about LeadMagic?

I am extremely dissatisfied with LeadMagic due to several issues. Firstly, the setup process, while easy, was misleading. They claimed to offer 100 fr

4. Error Handling
Users find the error handling in cancellation processes unclear, leading to unexpected billing and a lack of transparency.
See 1 mentions

See Related User Reviews

SK

Stanislav K.

Small-Business (50 or fewer emp.)

0.5/5

"Unclear cancellation flow, billed for months with no usage"

What do you dislike about LeadMagic?

We canceled in July and received a refund, but importantly, I had to confirm with support that the subscription was actually canceled because the proc

5. Filtering Difficulty
Users are frustrated by the filtering difficulty in LeadMagic, leading to inaccurate data and wasted resources.
See 1 mentions

See Related User Reviews

Sanim M.
SM

Sanim M.

0.5/5

"Shady Setup, Disappointing Experience"

What do you dislike about LeadMagic?

I am extremely dissatisfied with LeadMagic due to several issues. Firstly, the setup process, while easy, was misleading. They claimed to offer 100 fr

LeadMagic Reviews (20)

Reviews

LeadMagic Reviews (20)

4.3
20 reviews
Search reviews
Filter Reviews
Clear Results
G2 reviews are authentic and verified.
SK
Responsible for Marketing
Small-Business (50 or fewer emp.)
"Unclear cancellation flow, billed for months with no usage"
What do you like best about LeadMagic?

There are many similar tools on the market that offer comparable lead enrichment and workflows Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

What do you dislike about LeadMagic?

We canceled in July and received a refund, but importantly, I had to confirm with support that the subscription was actually canceled because the process/status was not fully clear. Later we reactivated in August and used the product briefly. After that, we stopped using it (credits kept accumulating), and I clearly remember canceling again in September, but billing continued for several months. The cancellation flow is not transparent enough, and it’s too easy to stay subscribed without realizing it.

Their Terms say “no refunds,” but their Help Center also says refund requests may be reviewed case-by-case, especially when credits were not used. I contacted support with billing and usage evidence and I’m still in correspondence, unfortunately, no refund has been processed yet.

Maybe I’m old-fashioned, but charging customers for months when the product is clearly not being used doesn’t feel like a sustainable long-term strategy, it erodes trust. A clearer cancellation confirmation and a fairer “unused months” resolution would go a long way. I’m still hoping this gets resolved as a goodwill refund for the unused months, based on the account usage records. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

André D.
AD
Cofundador
Small-Business (50 or fewer emp.)
"Exceptional Email Discovery with LeadMagic"
What do you like best about LeadMagic?

I enjoy the great support experience LeadMagic offers. It's an always evolving product that is cost effective. I appreciate how multiple enrichments are possible with a single credit system. LeadMagic's ability to find both business and personal emails is valuable, and the feature that lets me find LinkedIn profiles from emails really helps with my workflows. I also found the initial setup extremely easy, just a couple of clicks and a few minutes. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

What do you dislike about LeadMagic?

I think they could increase even more their email discovery rate, which is already great. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

Patrick S.
PS
Small-Business (50 or fewer emp.)
"Best B2B data enrichment in the Market"
What do you like best about LeadMagic?

LeadMagic has the best email finder, email validation, mobile data, and company data on the market. The API documentation is very thorough, and it’s easy to integrate and use, including in tools like Clay. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

What do you dislike about LeadMagic?

There's not much to dislike. If there was a traditional database, I could get rid of some other tools Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

Kevin M.
KM
Marketing Director
Small-Business (50 or fewer emp.)
"Great Tool - All In One Email Validation Tool Meets all Validation and Enrichment needs A**********"
What do you like best about LeadMagic?

We use lead magic primarily as a data enrichment tool for bulk lists of emails that we pull from other data platforms. Its great and using it really ensures that we clean our data lists before sending to ensure that our mailbox remain healthy and we don't end up in spam folders. Platform is easy to implement and very easy to use, its very straight forward, it integrates with all our Outbound tech stack and we use it weekly for creating email campaigns. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

What do you dislike about LeadMagic?

Like all data enrichment tools it doesn't get everything right 100% of the time but it is pretty much there in terms of what it offers for the cost. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

Sanim M.
SM
"Shady Setup, Disappointing Experience"
What do you like best about LeadMagic?

Nothing it's a scam product Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

What do you dislike about LeadMagic?

I am extremely dissatisfied with LeadMagic due to several issues. Firstly, the setup process, while easy, was misleading. They claimed to offer 100 free credits, but these were never provided, even after contacting their support team. The promised credits did not materialize, and the support's response was ineffective. Furthermore, the primary service feature, intended to enrich data by providing phone numbers, was largely inaccurate. Out of 100 attempts, fewer than 15 were successful, and most of these were either incorrect or fake numbers. This inaccuracy rendered my subscription to LeadMagic a complete waste of time, money, and effort, as it failed to deliver on its core promise, impacting my business operations negatively. Overall, the operations of LeadMagic appear to be deceitful, to the extent that I strongly perceive it as a scam. I regret investing in their service and wish to warn others not to fall for the same trap. I remain completely unsatisfied with any aspect of the service provided by LeadMagic. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

Verified User in Marketing and Advertising
UM
Small-Business (50 or fewer emp.)
"Beware: Good product with sketchy business practices"
What do you like best about LeadMagic?

Great enrichment product and reasonably priced Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

What do you dislike about LeadMagic?

After using the platform for a year and spending hundreds of dollars per month, they decided to remove 70k credits (more than $500 worth) from my account after accusing me of abusing their email finding api, saying that I was sending "fake names" to use it to find mx records of the domain. The fact is we target local businesses and was trying to find emails associated with their domain.

Just for context, we use 2 other email finders BEFORE Lead Magic (we use icypeas and findymail) and have never had any issues with them even though we are sending them the same contacts to enrich.

After following up multiple times for multiple days in a row to try to get on a call with their team to show them that I was in fact using their api for what it is supposed to be used for, I have received 0 responses from support. I would steer clear of their product, as a small business it's too risky to spend money on credits only to have them removed without question. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

Verified User in Marketing and Advertising
AM
Small-Business (50 or fewer emp.)
"High quality leads and amazing email verification"
What do you like best about LeadMagic?

We mainly use Apollo for finding leads, but sometimes it failes to deliver results.

LeadMagic has a way higher number of working leads for us Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

What do you dislike about LeadMagic?

Eveything is fine, they could add a way to get single phone numbers/email straight from the website UI. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

Wayne H.
WH
Small-Business (50 or fewer emp.)
"Best email validation and enrichment on the market"
What do you like best about LeadMagic?

There are 2 things you look at when picking a data provider: quality and price.

LeadMagic has the best price of the market and the quality is very good. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

What do you dislike about LeadMagic?

not much honestly, this is a very nice product overall Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

Christopher H.
CH
Business Development Manager
Small-Business (50 or fewer emp.)
"I broke my career-wide appointment setting KPI per hour record three times in a single week."
What do you like best about LeadMagic?

Jesse's ability to deliver high dial 2 connect rate leads where the prospect is likely to say YES to a meeting is incredibly high in comparison to everything I've had the fortune to cold call. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

What do you dislike about LeadMagic?

My outbound phone dialer provider still hasn't sponsored me yet after learning the news of my triumph. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

Terry W.
TW
Chief Executive Officer
Mid-Market (51-1000 emp.)
"1st party intent data - Incredible!"
What do you like best about LeadMagic?

You only pay for what you use - no monthly subscription!

Lead Magic shows me the company that has visited my website AND the individual (with their contact details!) and it happens in real-time. This allows us to very accurately and economically retarget them through our advertising. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

What do you dislike about LeadMagic?

There is nothing to dislike at this stage. Senior management is super helpful. Review collected by and hosted on G2.com.

Product Avatar Image
LeadMagic