What is a flat tax?
A flat tax, sometimes referred to as a proportional tax, refers to a system in which the same tax rate applies to all taxpayers with no deductions or exemptions allowed, regardless of income bracket. Some states that currently use a flat tax income system include Colorado, Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Massachusetts, Michigan, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, and Utah.
Accounting firms use tax services to save time and money when filing and preparing taxes. These providers can also ensure legal compliance and that tax deadlines are met.
How flat tax works
Suppose Employees A, B, and C work at the same organization in the same state. Their state’s government imposes a flat tax rate of 13%. Employee A is a senior leader and earns $175,000 in annual taxable income. Employee B is a business analyst and earns $100,000. Employee C is an office manager and earns $70,000.
In this example:
- Employee A pays $175,000 x 0.13 or $22,750 in annual taxes
- Employee B pays $100,000 x 0.13 or $13,000 in annual taxes
- Employee C pays $70,000 x 0.13 or $9,100 in annual taxes
After taxes, Employee A has $152,250 left over while Employee B has $87,000 and Employee C has $60,900.
Advantages of a flat tax
While there are different types of tax systems, a flat tax system provides unique advantages, including:
- Simplification: Applying a flat tax is straightforward. Other tax systems apply tax percentages based on income bracket, but a flat tax system eliminates that complexity. Time is saved by removing the need to determine taxpayers' calculations based on their salary.
- Consistency: A flat tax system is consistent in that all taxpayers are charged a uniform tax rate. Some suggest that a flat tax system is fairer than other tax systems because of its consistent tax percentage; however, flat tax offers consistency regardless of fairness.
- Straightforward interpretation: Since a flat tax system doesn’t allow exemptions or deductions, there’s less room for taxpayers to interpret tax rules and manipulate the regulations to their benefit. In progressive tax systems, specific individuals or groups could take advantage of many exemptions, deductions, and credits.
-
Reduction of double taxation: Double taxation occurs when income taxes are paid twice on the same income source. Flat tax systems help alleviate these instances.
Disadvantages of a flat tax
As with all types of tax systems, there are some disadvantages of flat tax worth considering, including:
- Disproportionate tax burden: Even though all taxpayers are taxed at the same rate, a flat tax system may shift a more significant burden to the lower and middle classes. Wealthier taxpayers don’t pay higher rates and still bring home a high amount of spending money.
- Reduced wealth distribution: With a flat tax system, wealthy taxpayers often remain wealthy, which means there aren’t a lot of shifts in the distribution of wealth. Some may consider this an unfair advantage, as it’s often more challenging for the lower and middle classes to pay off their debts, save money, and achieve similar levels of wealth when they lose significant portions of their taxable income.
Flat tax vs. progressive tax
Flat tax systems apply one tax rate to all taxpayers, regardless of income bracket. This type of tax system doesn’t allow for deductions or exemptions.
A progressive tax system applies taxes based on a tiered model in which higher incomes are taxed at higher percentages and lower incomes are taxed at lower rates. Progressive tax systems allow for deductions, exemptions, and credits.
Alyssa Towns
Alyssa Towns works in communications and change management and is a freelance writer for G2. She mainly writes SaaS, productivity, and career-adjacent content. In her spare time, Alyssa is either enjoying a new restaurant with her husband, playing with her Bengal cats Yeti and Yowie, adventuring outdoors, or reading a book from her TBR list.
